Comparison
Best Incident Response Companies: How Leading Firms Compare
At a glance
| Option | Best for |
|---|---|
| Mandiant (Google Cloud) | Large or high-profile breaches, especially suspected nation-state or advanced attackers |
| CrowdStrike | Organizations that want incident response and ongoing managed detection from one vendor |
| Palo Alto Networks Unit 42 | Companies whose cyber insurer lists Unit 42, or that already run Palo Alto products |
| Kroll | Incidents likely to involve litigation, regulators or breach notification |
| IBM X-Force | Large enterprises, especially existing IBM security customers |
| Arctic Wolf | Small and mid-sized businesses that want clear, published retainer terms |
| Cyber Centaurs | Smaller organizations and law firms that need forensics or expert witness work |
What we compared
- Response speed and retainer terms
- Forensic depth and legal support
- Cyber insurance panel coverage
- Recovery and remediation help
- Fit for small and mid-sized businesses
Mandiant (Google Cloud)
cloud.google.com/security/mandiant
Best for Large or high-profile breaches, especially suspected nation-state or advanced attackers
Strengths
- Deep investigative experience and threat intelligence.
- The retainer offers 24/7 access with stated two-hour response, and unused hours can go toward proactive work such as tabletop exercises and penetration tests.
Watch out for
- Premium pricing.
- Likely more firm than a small business with a simple incident needs.
CrowdStrike
www.crowdstrike.com
Best for Organizations that want incident response and ongoing managed detection from one vendor
Strengths
- Falcon Complete MDR includes hands-on remediation, so response is built into monitoring.
- Analysts can often restore systems remotely without reimaging.
Watch out for
- Strongest when you run the Falcon platform.
- Separate incident response engagements are priced as enterprise services.
Palo Alto Networks Unit 42
www.paloaltonetworks.com/unit42
Best for Companies whose cyber insurer lists Unit 42, or that already run Palo Alto products
Strengths
- Approved incident response provider for more than 70 cyber insurance carriers.
- Named a Leader in Forrester's 2024 incident response services Wave.
- Also offers MDR and advisory work.
Watch out for
- Enterprise pricing.
- Smaller organizations may wait behind larger retainer clients during busy periods.
Kroll
www.kroll.com/en/services/cyber
Best for Incidents likely to involve litigation, regulators or breach notification
Strengths
- Handles the full lifecycle, from forensics to recovery and breach notification, plus litigation support.
- On more than 50 cyber insurance panels.
- Its retainer credits can be used across other Kroll risk services.
Watch out for
- Retainer response targets vary by tier, with longer times at the entry level.
- Recovery work is delivered with a partner firm.
IBM X-Force
www.ibm.com/services/incident-response
Best for Large enterprises, especially existing IBM security customers
Strengths
- Subscription retainer with a 24/7 global hotline.
- Proactive options include compromise assessments, ransomware readiness reviews and cyber range exercises.
Watch out for
- IBM does not publish tier details, response commitments or pricing.
- Oriented to large organizations.
Arctic Wolf
arcticwolf.com/solutions/incident-response
Best for Small and mid-sized businesses that want clear, published retainer terms
Strengths
- Transparent retainer options, including one that covers a full incident with a stated three-hour response time, and a low-cost option with no prepaid hours.
- Preferred vendor on more than 30 insurance panels.
Watch out for
- Retainer terms and response times have changed over time, so confirm the current terms.
- Best value when paired with Arctic Wolf's own monitoring.
Cyber Centaurs
cybercentaurs.com
Best for Smaller organizations and law firms that need forensics or expert witness work
Strengths
- Boutique digital forensics and incident response firm.
- Covers ransomware, business email compromise and insider threats, with expert witness testimony in state and federal courts.
Watch out for
- Smaller team than the global firms.
- No ongoing monitoring service, and no published insurance panel listings.
How to use this comparison
When ransomware hits or an email account is taken over, the first hours decide how bad things get. An incident response (IR) firm investigates what happened, stops the attacker, helps you recover and documents everything for insurers, regulators and lawyers.
The firms above are among the most established names. They range from global consultancies to a boutique forensics firm. We have not ranked them with scores. They suit different organizations, so use the "best for" notes and the questions further down to shortlist two or three. Facts come from each firm's published information. See how we evaluate providers for our approach.
What we compared
- Response speed and retainer terms: how quickly the firm commits to start, and what a retainer includes.
- Forensic depth and legal support: whether findings will stand up to regulators, insurers and courts.
- Cyber insurance panel coverage: many policies only pay for firms on the insurer's approved list.
- Recovery and remediation help: whether the firm helps you rebuild, or only investigates.
- Fit for small and mid-sized businesses: price, minimums and attention for smaller clients.
Global firms vs. boutique firms
The big names (Mandiant, CrowdStrike, Unit 42, Kroll and IBM X-Force) bring large teams, broad threat intelligence and experience with the most serious attacks. They are the natural choice for a large breach, a regulated company, or an attack that may involve a nation-state. They also tend to cost the most, and a small business may not get their most senior people.
Smaller firms such as Cyber Centaurs, and providers built for the mid-market such as Arctic Wolf, can be faster to engage and easier to budget for. For a common incident, such as a single compromised mailbox or ransomware on a few machines, a capable smaller firm is often enough. Whatever its size, the right firm is one your insurer will pay for and that can start quickly.
Call your insurer first
If you have cyber insurance, call the insurer's breach hotline before you hire anyone. Most policies require you to use a firm on their approved panel. If you use another firm, you may pay its bill yourself. This is the single most common and expensive mistake companies make in the first hour. Our cyber insurance guide explains how policies handle incident response.
Retainer or on-demand?
You can hire an IR firm when something happens, or sign a retainer in advance.
- On-demand: no upfront cost, but you negotiate contracts and rates in the middle of a crisis, and you may wait behind retainer clients.
- Retainer: terms, rates and response times are agreed in advance. Many retainers let you use unused hours for proactive work, such as a tabletop exercise or an incident response plan, so the money isn't wasted in a quiet year.
For most organizations that handle sensitive data, a modest retainer with their insurer's preferred firm is worth considering. Our incident response services page explains typical pricing.
Questions to ask any incident response firm
- Are you on my cyber insurer's approved panel?
- What response time is written into the contract, and does it mean remote or on-site?
- Who does the recovery work: your team, a partner, or mine?
- Will you work with my outside lawyer, so findings can be protected by legal privilege?
- If I don't have an incident this year, what can retainer hours be used for?
- Do you need any software installed on my systems before an incident, to start faster?
Before an incident: get ready
Whichever firm you choose, you'll recover faster with a written incident response plan, offline backups that you have actually tested, and a contact list for your insurer, lawyer and IR firm. See our guide to small business cyber threats for the attacks most likely to hit you.
If you want help comparing incident response providers for your organization, you can get free quotes from vetted firms.
Sources
- Mandiant Retainer (Google Cloud)
- Unit 42 Cyber Threat Intelligence & Incident Response (Palo Alto Networks)
- Cyber Incident Response Retainer (Kroll)
- IBM X-Force Incident Response Services (IBM)
- Incident360 Retainer (Arctic Wolf)
Drafted with AI assistance, then edited and fact-checked by a person. How we use AI.
Want help choosing?
Tell us what you need and we will match you with up to three vetted providers. Free, with no obligation to hire.
Get free quotes