Cybersecurity Maturity Assessment

A cybersecurity maturity assessment measures how developed an organization's security practices are, from ad hoc to well managed and continuously improving, against a framework. It shows where you are and what to improve next.

IntermediateCategory: Governance and compliance

Also called: security maturity assessment, cybersecurity maturity model, maturity level, CSF tiers

What is a cybersecurity maturity assessment?

A checklist asks "Do you have this control?" A maturity assessment asks "How well and how consistently do you do it?" Having a backup is one thing; having automated, monitored, regularly tested backups with documented procedures is a higher level of maturity.

Maturity assessments score each area of security on a scale, typically from "nonexistent" or "ad hoc" to "optimized". The result is a picture of strengths and weaknesses and a roadmap for improving.

Common maturity models

  • NIST CSF Tiers: the NIST Cybersecurity Framework describes four tiers for how rigorously an organization governs and manages cyber risk: Tier 1 Partial, Tier 2 Risk Informed, Tier 3 Repeatable and Tier 4 Adaptive. It also uses current and target profiles to show where you are and where you want to be.
  • [CMMC](/glossary/cmmc/): the Department of Defense's Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification, with three levels tied to the type of information a contractor handles.
  • CIS Controls Implementation Groups: IG1, IG2 and IG3, increasing with organization size and risk.
  • Capability maturity scales (levels 0–5) used by many consultants and tools, scoring how defined, measured and improved each process is.

How it works

  1. Choose a framework, often the NIST CSF for small and mid-sized businesses.
  2. Gather evidence through interviews, document reviews and technical checks.
  3. Score each area for current maturity.
  4. Set a target based on your risks, industry and budget. Not every area needs the top level.
  5. Build a roadmap to close the most important gaps.
  6. Reassess yearly to show progress.

Free and paid options

CISA offers the free Cyber Security Evaluation Tool (CSET) for self-assessment. Many security assessment providers and virtual CISOs also offer maturity assessments, which are useful for reporting progress to leadership, boards and insurers. See our guide to risk assessment costs.

Related terms

Sources

  1. The NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 (NIST)
  2. Cyber Security Evaluation Tool (CSET) (CISA)

Drafted with AI assistance, then edited and fact-checked by a person. How we use AI.